American Society of Plastic Surgeons
For Medical Professionals
 

Nothing she can't do
An innovative plastic surgery procedure helped build a life defined by resilience


Christine Barnish of Oshkosh, Wis., was a long-time middle school language arts teacher. She knows the word "can't" exists in the English language, but it has never existed in her personal vocabulary, even after a childhood accident when she lost several fingers.

Barnish was seven years old when she came home from school one day in May to find her dad mowing the lawn on his riding mower. She would often ride in his lap as he did the chore.

"It had been several months since the last time I rode with my dad on the mower," said Barnish. "I couldn't fit on his lap anymore between the steering wheel, so he decided to put me on the hood instead. He had his left arm around my side to keep me safe, and we were going along just fine."

Low-hanging branches startled Barnish when they drove under a tree.

"I jumped back, and that's when I fell off the riding lawn mower," said Barnish. "It took the four fingers off my right hand and then the tips of my left fingers."

An innovative surgery offered a new path

Her dad rushed her to the ER, and then she was taken to the University of Wisconsin Children's Hospital, where she met Venkat Rao, MD.

"Christine had lost all of her fingers on the right hand," said Dr. Rao. "Her thumb was not injured. She also had injuries to several fingers of the left hand, but she only lost portions of the fingers of the left hand. This was a particularly bad injury."

Initially, Dr. Rao tried to reattach one finger to her right hand, but the surgery was unsuccessful.

"We went ahead and reattached the small finger of the right hand, and she lost it about three days later," said Dr. Rao.

Yet he was determined to find another way to give her a functional hand.

"He had the idea of the toe-to-hand transplant," said Barnish. "Which, as far as I know, was an innovative procedure at the time. He said there's this procedure where they can actually take your toes from each foot and then those will be just like your fingers."

Barnish said she and her parents felt it would be the best option to give her the most mobility.

"Because I loved to draw and paint so much at that time, I said to my dad I would like that because then I can still draw and color," said Barnish. "We knew it would give me the best shot at doing everything that I could possibly want with my life."

Dr. Rao said he had come across the toe-to-hand transplant in Australia, where he trained on the procedure.

"It's an operation that had been done in other parts of the world," said Dr. Rao. "It was fairly new, not so extensively done in the United States."

Barnish first needed a groin flap, where her right hand was attached to her groin area for about three weeks before the toe-to-hand transplant to provide enough skin for the procedure. Then, Dr. Rao removed the second toe from each foot and transplanted them to her right hand in a 13-hour operation. This allowed Barnish to have some grip strength in her hand.

"For us to be able to use a thumb, you need something for the thumb to go to," said Dr. Rao. "We hoped those two toes, now fingers, would help her grasp objects. It turned out over time that Christine had a lot of mobility in these toes and has been able to get extraordinary use of her right hand."

Learning to adapt

It took about eight months for Barnish to recover from the surgeries to her hands and feet. She said that because she was so young, she adjusted easily to her new fingers.

"My parents didn't make me feel like, oh, this is going to be a challenge for you," she said. "It was more, 'Let's do this, let's try this and we won't let it affect you.' So, I just learned to adapt right away and didn't miss a beat."

The only activity she was unable to do growing up was climb the monkey bars because of the weakened grip of her right hand. She went on to play instruments, including the trombone and piano, and several sports such as volleyball, cross country and track in middle and high school. As an adult, she has participated in triathlons, long-distance bike rides, cross-country skiing and golf. She considers herself ambidextrous.

"I really feel there's nothing I can't do," said Barnish. "I golf, I can play piano, I do yard work, make beaded jewelry and I can write with both hands. I eat with both hands. Just using both hands so equally really helped with the recovery process."

Her parents each encouraged her in different ways.

"My dad was more of 'You can do this. You don't need help. You can do this on your own. There's nothing you can't do,'" said Barnish. "My mom was extremely loving and always said, 'Oh, you're perfect. You got this. You're beautiful.' But they both were always encouraging me to do active things."

The first several years after her accident, she said she never felt different.

"In the early days, in that small community where the accident happened, I felt like everyone rallied around me," said Barnish.

That changed in middle school, where her difference led to bullying.

"I wasn't in the community where my accident happened," said Barnish. "There was a lot of teasing, being made fun of, kids assuming I wouldn't be able to play with them or be good at sports such as basketball or volleyball. I'd always be chosen last for a team. That was frustrating for me because I knew I could play those sports just as well. I may look different, but I'm an athlete. Those were tough, tough years of my life."

It could be especially difficult when adults would make her feel that she was unable to do something. There were two instances that stood out the most.

"Once in middle school and once in high school, an adult doubted me, and it really stuck with me," said Barnish. "Their doubts didn't allow me to do what I wanted to do. One was a band teacher. I wanted to play the clarinet or flute. He had me play the trombone because he didn't think I could do it. He didn't really know me then because if I do struggle at something, I'm going to figure out how to get over it. The other person was a high school volleyball coach who didn't think I would be able to play volleyball, so he didn't give me a chance. I was a pretty good volleyball player."

Pain turns to purpose

Eventually, Barnish became a middle school language arts teacher. She created a writing assignment for her students to allow them to share an important moment from their lives at the start of every school year.

"I called it 'My Most _____ Moment,' and I had them fill in the blank with anything they wanted," she said. "You can talk about your happiest moment, your scariest moment, your most embarrassing moment."

The example she shared was always her essay about her accident called "My Most Painful Moment." This was a way for her to connect with the students in a personal way and to help them feel comfortable sharing their own personal stories.

"I talked to them about how what made it the most painful wasn't physical pain because I don't really recall any," said Barnish. "I told the students that the pain came from being bullied in middle school and being doubted by those adults. I want my students to feel like no matter what you've experienced, what others may think of you, you can do anything that you put your mind to."

She also made her classroom a bully-free zone.

"I will not tolerate it," said Barnish. "I let them know how much it hurt me, and I don't want them to feel that same kind of pain."

Additionally, she coached the middle school volleyball team.

"I think the students were pretty impressed with what I was able to do as a coach," said Barnish. "They would see me during practice with them with serving, with getting right in there and passing the ball, hitting the ball and playing with them when we would scrimmage. They were surprised at how active and involved I was."

Lasting results

She also surprised Dr. Rao with her dexterity about 40 years after her surgery. The two recently reconnected, and he tested Barnish's hands.

"I got the sense that a lot of the medical staff that I met with that day were pretty impressed with what I was able to do and how I was able to do it," said Barnish. "I personally think I probably am able to do so much more than they anticipated I would. I can pick up small objects, but I can do very detailed, intricate tasks with my hands. A lot of these procedures plastic surgeons do, it's life changing. I'm just one person whose life has been changed by Dr. Rao."

Dr. Rao said he was impressed with Barnish's dexterity so many years later.

"I was very surprised by how mobile those toes, now fingers, are and how much feeling and sensation she has," he said. "She told us that she is able to feel a lot of objects. She is an extraordinary model of how people can progress with determination, even though she had a devastating injury to both hands during childhood."

Helping others delete "can't"

She taught language arts for 19 years and now works as an administrative assistant in the office with the school counselors, where she continues to encourage students to delete "can't" from their personal vocabulary.

"If people ever doubt you and you know you're capable, prove them wrong," said Barnish. "Show them you can do it. Tell them, 'I can do this. Don't doubt me,' and don't ever let those people make you think that you can't do something because you can."

To find a qualified plastic surgeon for any cosmetic or reconstructive procedure, consult a member of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons. All ASPS members are board certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery, have completed an accredited plastic surgery training program, practice in accredited facilities and follow strict standards of safety and ethics. Find an ASPS member in your area.

Logo

Patient Care Center